Technology
is creating new ethical problems for the broadcast media
in the United States, technology that is also being used
in Latin America.
One
issue involves digitally changing the background on televised
news stories. Another involves digitally compressing the
dialogue on live radio talk shows so that more commercials
can be used per hour.
Another
issue, which does not involve news nor technology, concerns
the submission of scripts for televised programs to the
White Houses to see if they compensate for anti-drug commercials.
When
CBS Evening News broadcast live from Times Square on New
Year's Eve, an advertisement for the program appeared on
the side of a building. The image containing the advertisement
was digitally inserted in the live programming to cover
up an advertisement for NBC, a competing network, which
had rented space on the building.
The
electronic insertion technology is provided by Princeton
Video Image, a company that includes Televisa of Mexico
among its clients. The company, known by its initials, PVI,
signed a contract last year with Columbia Broadcasting System
to provide the technology for the CBS Evening News and other
of the network's programs.
"We
were looking for some way to brand the neighborhood with
the CBS logo," said CBS executive producer Steve Friedman
of the network's desire to digitally place its logo in areas
around its New York headquarters. "It does not distort
the content of the news."
However,
Harry Jessell, the editor of Broadcasting & Cable magazine,
which first carried the story, disagrees with Friedman.
"I think it does raise some ethical questions for CBS,"
he said. "You would think that a TV news organization
would not tamper with video, especially live video. Viewers
should be able to rely on the fact that what they are seeing
is actually there."
Journalism
ethicists have pondered the question of when the manipulation
of images becomes unethical. The answer: when reality becomes
distorted.
PVI's
first involvement with the media was at sporting events,
digitally inserting advertisements on the space in front
of the grandstands.
El
Norte of Monterrey, Mexico, one of the most ethical
newspapers in the world, also does something with advertising
at sporting events. It airbrushes them out of photographs
it uses, on the grounds that they would constitute free
advertising in the newspaper.
Rush
Limbaugh, the foremost talk-show host on radio in the United
States, was surprised when listeners late last year started
sending him e-mails asking if there were more commercials
being placed on his three hour, live program. To his surprise,
he discovered that there were more commercials.
The
radio station originating the broadcast of Limbaugh's program
was using technology developed for television by a company
called Prime Image. The company's so-called Time Machine
compresses audio and visual signals on television to permit
more commercials.
Because
viewers are more conscious of space dedicated to commercials,
the technology was never a success in television, although
Prime Image's president, Bill Hendershot, said 250 stations
had purchased the Time Machine. The company, based in San
José, California, last year introduced a version for radio,
appropriately called Cash, or Dinero. "Listeners won't
even notice it," says Prime Image's Web site. "Yet
it allows broadcasters to add 60 seconds of commercial time
or more every 10 minutes. And it works in real time, right
on the air."
If
radio listeners in Latin America are like those of the Russ
Limbaugh show, they might notice the speeded up programs
because Prime Image markets Cash from offices in Mexico
City, Caracas, Buenos Aires and Santiago.
The
technology allows a radio station to eliminate pauses and
silent moments and speed up the conversation. When Limbaugh
realized what was happening, he said that he paused for
dramatic effect. The station stopped using the technology
on his program.
Again,
was reality being distorted, or just speeded up, by the
technology?
All
major networks were embarrassed when Salon.com, the Internet
news organization, revealed that they had submitted over
100 episodes of some of their programs, such as "ER,"
"Chicago Hope," "General Hospital,"
"Trinity," "Providence" and "Beverly
Hills 90210" to the White House's Office of National
Drug Control Policy run by the federal drug czar, Gen. Barry
R. McCaffrey. The networks – ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox, WB and
UPN – did so because of a $200 million a year anti-drug
advertising campaign approved by Congress in 1997. Under
it, the networks were to provide a free anti-drug commercial
for every one the government bought.
When
the networks found that they were selling all of their advertising
space and had none to give to the government, an arrangement
was worked out with the White House drug office under which
they were given credit for anti-drug messages in the shows
they carried. Hence submission of scripts.
"Has
the federal government embarked on an illegal payola scam
with the nation's television networks?" asked Salon.com,
which spent six months investigating the issue.
All
networks denied that they were giving creative control of
their programs to the White House.
Alan
Levitt, an official in the drug policy office, told The
New York Times that the networks saved over $20 million
by including anti-drug scenes or messages in the scripts.
"It
sounds like a form of propaganda that is, in effect, for
sale," said media watchdog Bill Kovach, curator of
the Nieman Foundation at Harvard University.
Said
The New York Times in a lead editorial January 18:
"… it is a deeply unhealthy arrangement that should
disturb anyone who believes in the need for all media –
the entertainment industry as well as the networks – to
remain free from government meddling."
The
publicity given the issue prompted the White House to drop
the review of scripts. "There can be no suggestion
of federal interference in the creative process," said
General McCaffrey in a letter to the news media January
19. "Accordingly, in the future we will review programs
for pro bono match consideration only after they have been
broadcast."